Rules committee has spoken

[MUMac]

I don't care much either way, because how often is a five second closely guarded rule even called? My guess is way less than once per game.

That is only looking at it one way. Without the rule, ball movement could suffer - more one on one type plays, rather than move the ball. Without the rule, there is no consequence. Everyone knew of the 5 second closely guarded rule and avoided it, which is why it is rarely called.

Heck, if you take your point, do away with the 5 second inbound, 10 second to cross half court and 3 second rules as well. They are seldom called either.