Okay...long post alert...
We need to make some alterations to compete with Belgium. Two of the biggest problems this team has had are set piece delivery and the curious case of Michael Bradley. I hoped to see Davis take set pieces in the last match, but Klinsmann seems set with Zusi when he's in there and Bedoya when he isn't. Zusi's delivery has been very poor since the perfectly placed cross to Brooks for the Ghana winner. At this point, I'd rather see Dempsey, Bradley, or someone else (Mix?) take a crack.
The other problem seems to largely be created because Bradley has had to run so damn much (more than any other player this World Cup) due to the Altidore injury. Bradley's regular defensive duties have been compounded with a need to play the underneath role usually frequented by Dempsey. The Portugal game really stood out for me. Bradley was a beast in the first half, winning balls, attacking, and had the game ended there you could have argued he was our best player. In the second half, he got winded and simply couldn't connect up, all punctuated by the awful giveaway that led to Ronaldo's delivery for the winner.
My real issue with us though is how similar our attackers are. Whether it's Beasley and Johnson making long runs from the back, Bradley or Jones making surging box-to-box runs through the midfield, or Zusi and Bedoya charging up the wings, it seems everyone needs the ball at their feet to be most effective. There's only one ball, and you can't have 7 players (including Dempsey, best on the team with the ball at his feet) that all need the ball on their feet to be effective. Which is why I feel it's the time for Mix Diskerud.
If I'm Klinsmann, I'd consider something like this:
Dempsey
Diskerud ----- Johnson
Jones ----- Beckerman ----- Bradley
Beasley ----- Besler ----- Cameron ----- Yedlin
Howard
It's not that different from what we've been playing. Jones and Beasley have formed an able pair on the left, covering each other defensively and getting the ball up the pitch. Having Yedlin and Johnson together would keep one RB back at all times and provide a more defensive (but also faster) look than Zusi in there. That also allows Bradley to be a defensive safety valve both for the right side and Hazard as well as Beckerman dealing with De Bruyne in the middle. The real differences are Johnson taking Zusi's role primarily, Jones returning to the role he played against Ghana, but adding a quick-touch facilitator in Diskerud. One of the problems we've had this competition is interlinking in the final third. Diskerud is the only player on our team who generally already knows what he will do with the ball before he gets it. One or two touches and it's on to the next player. He won't try to get fancy, dribble around, and give the defense time to take the ball.
The only player on the roster that can hold up the ball allowing the midfielders to run on to him is Altidore. Without him in there, a change is needed. Diskerud will allow the USA to hold possession by transitioning quickly from right to left and back to front. When we've tried to hold the ball without Altidore, we've seen too many giveaways in the final third. Diskerud's mindset reduces the odds of that happening. He's not the defensive presence that Zusi or Bedoya are, but with Jones and Bradley flanking Beckerman and Johnson covering the young Yedlin there's enough presence at the back. Frankly, no amount of defense will ever really be "enough" for a team with the wealth of attacking options Belgium has, and the best way to reduce pressure is to actually apply some of our own in the final third. If Jozy isn't ready for 90 minutes, Diskerud is the only player on the roster that addresses that.
While this does take out our free kick takers, I'm willing to risk that. For direct kicks, Dempsey will take them anyway, and for crosses, we can't do much worse than we have (excepting Zusi's corner to Brooks).
Belgium has barely scraped by this World Cup despite winning all three. They came from behind against Algeria and all of their winners have been scored after the 75th minute. Using Diskerud will help the USA maintain possession (which worked well for Russia and South Korea for much of the game) and keep options like Zusi and Bedoya available off the bench to inject some late pace when in the past Belgium has been able to surge past teams with three of four goals coming from substitutes.
Relieve defensive pressure by maintaining meaningful possession, partner Dempsey with other attack-minded players that excel with minimal touches, and have energy off the bench to counteract Belgium's late strength and I fully believe the USA can win. But if we just do what wasn't quite enough to get desired results against Portugal and Germany, I fear the USA will be bowing out in the Round of 16 in back-to-back World Cups.